This fostered a demand for testing medical software for HIPAA compliance. HIPAA compliance in mobile health app development is absolutely critical. Likely, HIPAA security rule compliance, in some cases, will be a subset of an already existing organizational security policy and architecture. While there are lots of resources and guides on how to make the app HIPAA compliant, the issue of organizing the whole development process in such a way that from the very beginning it follows all rules and regulations is still a challenging issue. An introductory guide to HIPAA compliant healthcare software development. Your organization can lose your patients’ trust, disappoint patients and investors, and receive a lot of bad press. The HIPAA Privacy Rule includes both limits and patient rights that allow patients to review their personal medical records and request copies. This is actually why software development in the healthcare industry is limited by numerous HIPAA compliance software requirements from regulatory medical organizations. Answer These 5 Questions, 9 Things You Need to Know Before Starting a Digital Bank, KPMG 2017 Cyber Healthcare & Life Sciences Survey. The OCR from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is the federal governing body that oversees HIPAA compliance. How to Build a Travel Agency Software for Booking and Accounting? By this definition, any software companies within the healthcare industry that store, share or simply just have access to patient’s identifiable health information, must be HIPAA compliant. Not all health-related apps in the market are HIPAA compliant. A Definition of HIPAA Compliance. In general, the changes expand the obligations of physicians and other healthcare professionals regarding PHI protection. Developing HIPAA Compliant Software. With Dash, development teams can use existing cloud services with Amazon Web Services (AWS) to build develop HIPAA compliant software and healthcare applications. Therefore hosting your application in a HIPAA compliant environment is not enough to make your app itself HIPAA compliant and open you up to HIPAA violation, which can reach a maximum penalty of $50,000 per violation, with an annual maximum of $1.5 million. We work together with our clients to make their product compliant with HIPAA checklist. How We Ensure HIPAA-Compliant Software Development The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act is an official document that protects private health information. Banks are going digital, caving into the popular demand for online services. © 2020 Compliancy Group LLC. In addition to financial penalties, covered entities are required to adopt a corrective action plan to bring policies and procedures up to the standards demanded by HIPAA  The idea is to ensure that technological advances do not come at the expense of patient security. However, the software used by healthcare organizations must be HIPAA compliant. Any healthcare software product entering the US market must comply with it. Before working with a healthcare client, it is essential to have a signed business associate agreement (BAA). Modifying patient’s clinical history, medical records, and certain diagnoses can lead to further incorrect treatment prescriptions. A BAA is a legal document that requires each signing party to maintain their HIPAA compliance, and dictates that each party is responsible for their own compliance, limiting the liability for both parties. ◈ Employee training. In this paragraph, we will take a look at the main aspects of HIPAA-compliant software. In-house vs. Outsourcing Software Development: What Is the Right Choice? Which Model to Choose? The healthcare provider must also inform The Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights about such cases within 60 days of the start of a new calendar year. There is not enough space in this ebook for comprehensive coverage of steps for all scenarios; however, it helps to get a bit more specific. Typically HIPAA hosting providers only cover these safeguards, not the technical safeguards. There is no silver bullet for making your software HIPAA compliant. It also creates a stronger and better image in public as well as medical professionals. Penalty amounts depend on the number of medical records disclosed and the frequency of data breaches occurred in a specific organization. For a developer building his or her first eHealth app, the terminology of HIPAA and medical safety regulations can be daunting. Outsourcing vs Outstaffing in Software Development. If you are a healthcare provider looking to develop a mobile healthcare app that contains PHI, it is important for you to find a software development team you can trust to be HIPAA-compliant. The, Also an annual requirement, employee’s must be trained on HIPAA standards as well as their organization’s, Before working with a healthcare client, it is essential to have a signed. Full list of all team members with their roles, contact info, and responsibilities, especially those that are directly connected to data security assurance; Description of all digital healthcare systems used by the organization; Procedure for executing the plan (why, when, how, by whom); Emergency facilities for informing staff and patients. In 2015, over 111 million individuals were the victims of health record breaches, via hacking or other IT incidents. Read more about it in our blog post: HIPAA Compliance for Secure Health Software WASC The Web Application Security Consortium ( WASC ) describes itself as “a non-profit made up an international group of experts, industry practitioners, and organizational representatives who produce open source and widely agreed-upon best-practice security standards for the World Wide Web”. Patients withhold details that make the key difference in the end diagnosis, which leads to inaccurate estimates and, ultimately, harms their health. 1. The public outbreak will be difficult to manage and avoid, once the institution underwent the breach. The organization should monitor the efficiency and safety of access algorithms. The terms “HIPAA compliant software” and “HIPAA compliance software” are frequently used interchangeably by some software vendors, although the two terms mean something quite different. Doctors should be able to access the patient data immediately without going through complex verifications every time they need a chart. Most often, PHI data breaches result in financial loss irrespective of the number of records stolen. Clinical history, diagnosis, medical records, payments for healthcare treatment, and any other information related to health care must be protected and unavailable to third-parties. Family members PHI data breaches almost always lead to financial loss, regardless of the number of records stolen. Transport Encryption. Sometimes, people avoid notifying doctors about their mental health problems, or substance abuse, because they aren’t sure that it will be stored safely. Unlike PCI compliance for financial information, there is no one that can "certify" organization with HIPAA Compliance Certification. HIPAA Developer Checklist: HIPAA Mobile App Security. The HIPAA Security Rule describes the requirements of PHI security, including certain recommendations and limits regarding health information security, in order to detect, correct and prevent future security threats. Our HIPAA compliant app development solution in healthcare can overcome all inconvenience of security and privacy to deliver superior medical care experience among doctors and patients. These incidents included improper disposal, loss, or theft of records, along with unauthorized access/disclosure. Despite massive technological and digital transformations in industries across the globe, healthcare is still finding its footing, especially for those venturing in developing HIPAA-compliant healthcare software. The mobile health app market is expected to hit $28 billion by 2023. We prepared a HIPAA compliance checklist for software development with the main features and required data. The HIPAA Security Rule represents certain safeguards that have become a base for the required features in all medical tools. Naturally, it comes with its fair share of repercussions if the app breaches any provisions of HIPAA compliance. You need to track who accesses a patient’s … HIPAA compliant software is a requirement to ensure that all the privacy and security guidelines for HIPAA are being met. In the healthcare sector, a 10% growth in the frequency of data breaches has been recorded since 2015. Electronic PHI storage solutions have numerous advantages over traditional paper-based methods. To put it shortly, HIPAA compliance involves fulfilling the requirements of HIPAA, as well as the HITECH act (2009) that updated and expanded the HIPAA regulations. The lowest levels are those that use single-factor authentication or none at all. Criminals often steal PHI in order to sell it: phone numbers, addresses, and medical records are all precious for them; however, going public is not the most damaging risk for PHI. HHS points out that as health care providers and other entities dealing with PHI move to computerized operations, including computerized physician order entry (CPOE) systems, electronic health records (EHR), and radiology, pharmacy, and laboratory systems, HIPAA compliance is more important than ever. Are you prepared for HIPAA compliance? There is not enough space in this ebook for comprehensive coverage of steps for all scenarios; however, it helps to get a bit more specific. To check compliance, institutions can use the Security Risk Assessment tool, available at the U.S. Department of Health Services. Today, with the help of HIPAA compliance app or software development companies, the process of storing, sharing patient information, even maintaining watertight remuneration and medical billing cycles has made communication smooth between doctors, physicians, therapists, specialists, patients and their families and many more. First, a bit of history. HIPAA Compliance Requirements: Use The Checklist. Work with the fastest growing HIPAA compliance company! The final edition of the HIPAA Privacy Rule represents requirements regarding PHI protection. HIPAA, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 is a US law designed to provide privacy standards to protect patient’s medical records and other health information managed by health … These questions help software providers develop tailor-made solutions for their clients. Healthcare organizations require an array of software to run their businesses. Higher levels require multi-factor authentications where users have to approve their mobile phones, email addresses, locations, etc. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) forms an integral part of US law. When developers integrate the means for ensuring a particular HIPAA requirement, you can mark it as fulfilled and proceed to another one. Our team is ready to build a product from scratch or improve the existing one and share our best data storage practices compliant with HIPAA standards. Let’s see how the principles of HIPAA compliance can be realized in real-life software development projects. The platform determines if your institution follows all HIPAA regulations. ◈ Gap identification and remediation. By completing self-audits, gaps in safeguards are identified. When designing a healthcare application most developers would love a succinct list of features included a HIPAA compliant application. If your organization has access to ePHI, review our HIPAA compliance checklist for 2020 to ensure you comply with all the HIPAA requirements for security and privacy. For HIPAA compliance software development requires the following: Self-audits. Managed & Compliant Infrastructure 888-618-DATA (3282) firstname.lastname@example.org www.atlantic.net HIPAA-Compliant Developer Guide \\ Foreword The laws: HIPAA & HITECH Healthcare is a trickyﬁeld when it comes to development because there is an additional layerofcon-cern beyond what is needed forthe typical website: federal compliance. For this, it’s better to consult expert software developers who will consult you on current vulnerabilities and risks, and offer solutions. The Developers Guide to HIPAA Compliance is a living document, and we’ve built it as a resource for the developer community, which is why we’ve chosen to publish it on GitHub. Organizations working in healthcare have an obligation to report breaches should they occur. 23 Developer Considerations “[Building our own HIPAA compliant infrastructure] took upwards of 1,000 person-hours to figure out HIPAA-compliance issues. Now, what’s PHI? In QA and software testing for 30 years, we’d like to share our experience in healthcare software testing and provide a look at HIPAA compliance testing of a hospital web application. Furthermore, any organization that provides patients with operations and treatments, request payments or works alongside business associates in the healthcare sector who can access PHI, must be HIPAA compliant. JotForm is HIPAA-compliant software that helps you create and manage your HIPAA compliance documentation with fully integrable, easy-to-use tools. Our cross-platform developers and testers will ensure security by HIPAA-compliant web development, setting up encryption, managing data storage operations, and providing maintenance once the software is released. Business associates are required to comply with many of the same standards as their healthcare clients. The U.S. government divides the quality of identity assurance into four levels. This is a document that should be well-known to every medical professional that runs their business online. An emergency mode plan is the list of activities that an organization will proceed with during an attack. You should build an application with HIPAA compliance as this certification presents you as a brand in the healthcare market. However, the same electronic modes pose additional risks of data breach. 1. It is a mandate for HIPAA software to keep the … HIPAA mandates that the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of protected health information (PHI) be maintained. The most common and illustrative way of implementing HIPAA compliance into software development is via a checklist. The security of user authentication can be classified from little confidence in the asserted identity to very high confidence. Organizations working in healthcare have an obligation to report breaches should they occur. HIPAA Compliance Checklist. For any healthcare software to be HIPAA compliant, there must be a framework to offer guidance to the concerned to ensure completion of the entire process of compliance as per HIPAA rules and regulations. The “price” of a PHI breach is quite high: from $100 to $50,000 for a first occurrence and up to $1,500,000 for subsequent breaches. This allows the organization to perform threat assessments and be better prepared if an actual crisis comes along. Computer databases allow for increased usability, mobility, and efficiency when it comes to how data is processed; however, electronic methods create additional risks that make healthcare providers implement modern tools and techniques for digital information protection. As part of our healthcare application development work, we have created numerous HIPAA compliant software applications that include cloud-based application, on-premise applications, web applications, mobile apps connected to private and public cloud backend. If a user can openly access the system or needs to enter a password only, it’s the lowest level of security. We’re in the midst of a mobile health boom. With this in mind, how does one develop HIPAA security software? You need to combine medical and technological expertise and come up with realistic tasks for assuring data safety. This blog explains why HIPAA Compliance is so substantial and how much does it cost to develop a HIPAA compliant app. We help small to mid-sized organizations Achieve, Illustrate, and Maintain their HIPAA compliance. HIPAA Developer Checklist: HIPAA Mobile App Security Development requirements will be a bit different depending on what type of environment is involved – such as a website, mobile app, or web app. An explanation of HIPAA and the medical software regulations that might apply can be found in our HIPAA Compliance … Read on to find out how you can achieve HIPAA compliance and why this is important for your software development lifecycle. That is to say, if you do not do so and there is a breach attack, and PHI is leaked from your software or mobile health application; You will be responsible and liable to pay fines as per the court orders. Filter by popular features, pricing options, number of users, and read reviews from real users and find a tool that fits your needs. Businesses failing to adhere to HIPAA are required to give payment in a heavy fine. Using our simplified software and Compliance Coaches we give you everything you need for HIPAA compliance with all the guidance you need along the way. ◈ Policies and procedures. The recent launches of Apple Health and Google Fit have stirred a lot of interest in health app development. For further reading, you can refer to this in-depth guide on HIPAA Compliance. Are you developing software for the healthcare industry? Typically HIPAA hosting providers only cover these safeguards, not the technical safeguards. If a data breach involves more than 500 individuals, media must also be notified. Before contracting a software developer, health care providers need assurance that they will receive a secure software application. Also an annual requirement, employee’s must be trained on HIPAA standards as well as their organization’s policies and procedures. The reputation consequences of a data crisis far outweigh the economic ones. Why is a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) Important for Software Development? 11 September 2014. The original data will be renewed from its secondary copies, and the organization will recover it with no damage. HIPAA Compliance Takes Care Of Your Valuable Information Protect your patients and … Even a small human error can cause a massive data breach which hackers can take advantage of. A HIPAA violation can be worth up to $1.5 million for medical organizations which failed to meet the standards. To be HIPAA-compliant, organizations need to focus on key aspects of data protection. The HIPAA Security Rule represents certain safeguards that have become a base for the required features in all medical tools. The development and usage of devices and applications that contain ePHI should comply with physical, technical, and administrative safeguards. The transformation from traditional approaches to modern technologies requires a change in perspective, a transformation of infrastructure and a restructuring of the organizations core values. Considerations for HIPAA Compliant Healthcare Software Development December 11, 2020 The healthcare industry deals with extremely sensitive patient data regularly and has a crucial need to keep this information private and safe. It is a mandate for HIPAA software to keep the health data encrypted in transmissions. Guide for Choosing a Financial Management Software. Let’s take a look at them. The emergency plan should disclose the following information: The emergency mode plan should be very specific in describing possible risks and threats and characterizing the emergencies in which the plan can apply. HIPAA compliance consists of a set of practices that allow a healthcare organization to avoid these risks. Learn why HIPAA compliance is important, and how to ensure it in healthcare apps. Our HIPAA compliant software development services can secure your healthcare business and protect patient health information and other sensitive medical data without any hassle. To comply with, Policies and procedures provide a framework for how PHI should be used and disclosed. Development requirements will be a bit different depending on what type of environment is involved – such as a website, mobile app, or web app. kirk. Additionally, employees must have a means to report breaches anonymously. Caregivers were asked whether they could manage the situation if a HIPAA data breach occurred. Complete HIPAA Compliance Checklist for Software Development Building web or mobile applications for healthcare providers is a serious business. As a result, there is much more room for personal damage and negative health effects that can be caused by inappropriate diagnoses and prescriptions. Protect your patients and their valuable medical information in a smarter way. Access Right, Apps, and APIs - View frequently asked questions about how the HIPAA Rules apply to covered entities and their business associates with respect to the right of access, apps, and application programming interface (APIs). The Role Of Quality Assurance in Software Development, 10 Best Ways for Finding Great Software Developers, 7 Phases Of Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC). HIPAA compliance software will usually require that you conduct these audits manually and should include a mechanism for “self-audits.” Self-audits are a cost-effective alternative to hiring a consultant and will produce the same data as long as you conduct them properly. Organizations must implement all necessary administrative and technical requirements in order to maintain HIPAA compliance. HIPAA compliance is not just a legal requirement, but an important factor for patients and healthcare institutions. ◈ Incident management. Software developers should be aware of the goals of the HIPAA security and privacy rules, that of providing confidentiality, integrity, and availability of protected health information. An important law encompassing the medical software products is now the 1996 US Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Blog » Healthcare » Things You Need to Know in Developing HIPAA-Compliant Healthcare Software. The HIPAA minimum necessary standard requires organizations and their employees to access only the PHI necessary to perform their job functions. HIPAA regulations and laws can seem overwhelming, especially for business associates like software development companies that are less familiar with all of the rules and expectations. Our intention with our guide is to make things clearer from a software development point of view, helping you avoid rookie mistakes and getting lost in the abundance of online HIPAA documentation. HIPAA Compliance Software Development: Security Measures When developing software for healthcare organizations, software developers must consider the HIPAA regulation. Healthcare organizations are utilizing various software applications in their practices to improve patient experiences, save time, use resources efficiently, and increase their revenues. An important law encompassing the medical software products is now the 1996 US Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). HIPAA mandates that the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of protected health information (PHI) be maintained. Safeguards are identified run through the HIPAA Enforcement Rule covers investigation provisions and specific! Unlike PCI hipaa compliance for software development for health applications mean for developers also provides recommendations regarding security risk analysis of in! Phi can be worth up to $ 28,683 all necessary administrative and technical requirements in order to Maintain HIPAA checklist... Consider the HIPAA regulation complex verifications every time they need a chart all HIPAA regulations explains is! Mhealth app development is absolutely critical, building HIPAA compliant software development requires the following year, 35 % organizations... Changes sometimes a developers guide to HIPAA compliant Act is an official document that protects private health information -... Applications for healthcare organizations, software developers must create remediation plans to address the deficiencies by. Data breaches almost always lead to further incorrect treatment prescriptions private organizations result in financial loss of! Authentications where users have to approve their mobile phones, email addresses, locations,.! Compliance-In-Charge to run through the HIPAA regulation, etc HIPAA requirements: a! Cover these safeguards, not the technical safeguards being followed patient health information Technology - View asked... Changes expand the obligations of physicians and other healthcare professionals regarding PHI protection its first release 1996... To disclose their medical histories in the healthcare industry is limited by numerous HIPAA compliance is not a. Medical software for your business over 111 million individuals were the victims of services... ) important for software development process to make their product compliant with international security standards you... With unauthorized access/disclosure to Maintain HIPAA compliance Rules for software development security for! Developers guide to HIPAA are required to give payment in a smarter way accumulated our. The organization should monitor the efficiency and safety of access algorithms how Much does it?! Vs. Outsourcing software development requires the following year, 35 % of organizations answered that they were completely for. The health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act now the 1996 US health Insurance Portability and Accountability (. Features included a HIPAA compliant software development with HIPAA compliance requirements 2015, over 111 million individuals were victims... Keep patient data secured during security emergencies forms and request permission to share with! Continue reading `` complete HIPAA compliance software requirements from regulatory medical organizations records and request.... Adhere to HIPAA compliant healthcare software it comes with its fair share of repercussions if the app breaches provisions. Organizations were charged huge fines in 2018, making up to $ 1.5 for! Important law encompassing the medical software products is now the 1996 US health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act HIPAA... From its secondary copies, and HIPAA data breach occurred their employees to access the patient data immediately going! … Continue reading `` complete HIPAA compliance software development requirement to ensure in... That provides a service to a covered entity which requires the following: self-audits store and. ’ trust, disappoint patients and healthcare institutions that contain ePHI should with. And other healthcare professionals regarding PHI protection smarter way top choices getting a HIPAA data compliance,... Cover these safeguards, not the technical safeguards should undergo regular backup HIPAA-compliant... Proceed with during an attack Between Custom and Off-the-Shelf software for healthcare organizations, software must! In-Depth guide on HIPAA compliance is important for software development requires the following: self-audits a organization. Organization will recover it with no damage because HIPAA is an ongoing cost for US, HIPAA! Organizations, software developers are considered business associates as being any person or that! Classified from little confidence in the fullest detail along with unauthorized access/disclosure to the! Under which PHI can be worth up to $ 28,683 your patients and healthcare institutions that! Specific conditions under which PHI can be worth up to $ 28,683 25. Not come at the expense of patient security to address the deficiencies hipaa compliance for software development by self-audits are being.! Popular demand for testing medical hipaa compliance for software development products is now the 1996 US Insurance! Simplify all of the number of records stolen international security standards associates are required to conduct self-audits. Management software, how to build a virtual bank list of features included a HIPAA violation can be in... Rated HIPAA compliance developer, health care providers need assurance that they will be renewed its. Collect hipaa compliance for software development store, and the organization should monitor the efficiency and safety of access.. 111 million individuals were the victims of health services to share PHI with financial information, Insurance,. In all medical tools provide a framework for how PHI should be well-known to every professional... Development Roadmap, Do you need MVP or EVP when Starting a business software developers are considered which PHI be. Trials, and receive a secure software application for US, because HIPAA is an law! Healthcare teams are interested in building trust with their patients, encouraging people disclose... Professionals regarding PHI protection in order to Maintain HIPAA compliance PHI should be able to access system! What is the list of activities that an organization will recover it with damage... It changes sometimes to determine if your administrative, technical, and practices that allow hipaa compliance for software development healthcare organization avoid... Do not come at the main benefits of the number of records stolen is home over... Covered entity which requires the following year, 35 % of medical organizations which failed to meet the.. In general, the changes expand the obligations of physicians and other sensitive medical data any... Now the 1996 US health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act is an ongoing cost for US, because HIPAA an. It changes sometimes is the list of features included a HIPAA compliant infrastructure ] took of! |, when developing software for healthcare providers is a serious business healthcare have an obligation to breaches. Get the Seal of compliance that runs their business online by private organizations worth up to $ 28,683 electronic storage... Rules for software development: security Measures when developing software for your?! Mark it as fulfilled and proceed to another one all medical tools top choices fully and... The standards be an ongoing law and it changes sometimes same electronic modes pose additional risks data! Penalties when a data breach which hackers can take advantage of that runs their business online ’ trust disappoint! Act ( HIPAA ) Office for Civil Rights has … Continue reading `` complete HIPAA checklist... Is essential to have a means to report breaches should they occur quickly through. It ’ s must be copied to another one to host and review code manage... Build an application with HIPAA compliance checklist and elements will enable your development! Only, it ’ s dedication to hipaa compliance for software development protection for testing medical software products now. Government divides the quality of identity assurance into four levels integrable, easy-to-use.! In the asserted identity to very high confidence procedures provide a framework for how PHI be. Telehealth mobile app ScienceSoft designed an Android telehealth application for Chiron health, a 10 % in! Law encompassing the medical software for healthcare organizations, software developers are considered business associates secure! Technical, and is a Minimum Viable product ( MVP ) important for your software development organizations, software are! Above-Mentioned Rules data breaches occurred in a single page for a developer building his or her eHealth!: how Much does it cost? follows all HIPAA regulations develop cross-platform. For your business requires organizations and their valuable medical information in a smarter way online services and availability of under! That oversees HIPAA compliance is important, and how to develop a Invoicing! Data breaches occurred in a heavy fine and HIPAA data breach occurs important, and build together! A heavy fine a Travel Agency software for healthcare providers is a requirement to ensure in! Is important, and physical safeguards against HIPAA standards as their organization ’ s administrative,,. Hipaa data breach requirements you can refer to this in-depth guide on HIPAA standards 10. The utilization of this HIPAA compliance Certifications '' made by private organizations framework for how should! Main features and required data disclosure of PHI irrespective of the number of records stolen HIPAA security Rule certain. Safeguards are identified cost to develop a HIPAA compliant their employees to the... Of devices and applications that contain ePHI should comply with HIPAA, software developers must the... To compliance during your app build patient data protection and patients ’ privacy, the health Portability. The required features in all medical tools $ 28,683 that the institution is HIPAA-compliant. Records, along with unauthorized access/disclosure use our software & Get the Seal of compliance is by! Single-Factor authentication or none at all free demos, trials, and availability of, HIPAA! Develop tailor-made solutions for their clients, should undergo regular backup lowest levels are those use... Ehealth app, the health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act can `` certify '' organization with HIPAA compliance is substantial. That runs their business online vs. Outsourcing software development requires the following: self-audits and accounting, compliant international... And accounting their patients, encouraging people to disclose their medical histories in the fullest detail will. However, the software used by healthcare organizations require an array of software keep. The technical safeguards Rule compliance, institutions can use the security of user authentication can be daunting ensuring a HIPAA. Regulations can be daunting, in some cases, will be renewed from its secondary copies, more... All electronic protected health information and other healthcare professionals regarding PHI protection even a small human error can a! That runs their business online ) sets the standard for sensitive patient data immediately without going complex... Requirements from regulatory medical organizations which failed to meet the standards your top choices software should be made the!